The topic at the house for the last couple days has been public school or homeschool. Stormtrooper is adamantly against homeschooling, so there's that hurdle to jump across. And a rather large one at that. I have a list of reasons why I think it would be a good fit for our family, but maybe I'm blinded because it's my idea. Perhaps Stormtrooper is blinded against it because it's not his.
First, to get it out of the way, I never thought I would homeschool. I never thought I would think about homeschooling. Second, I don't want to create my own curriculum or anything of the sort. I want to enroll J in an online, cyber school, with me to be there to help guide him through the classes at a comfortable pace. There are a couple of options in our state of online public school.
So why homeschooling?
J has certain struggles in school. Academically he is doing fantastic, but I always wonder if his behavior doesn't keep him from striving further or excelling more. I think allowing him to learn at a different pace would give him the opportunity to work through his best subjects more quickly, giving him more time to work on the subjects he has more trouble with. Which, as a straight-A student, he doesn't struggle with much. On his most recent report card, he got a 92 in Reading and he was unhappy with that grade. I know there have been times during Reading or Language Arts where he has started to meltdown or couldn't transition because he was struggling with some of the themes they were working on. He loves to read and reads at a high grade level, but when it comes time to what motivates characters, what they are thinking or feeling, he has an extremely difficult time figuring it out. When it comes to creative writing, he almost cannot do it at all, and it's a struggle and a fight with his teacher to get him to even attempt to try. For subjects like that, a more unlimited timeframe for him to finish those tasks/subjects would probably make a world of difference.
The problem with a lot of children with high-functioning autism is that they are special needs kids, but because they're of average to above-average intelligence, they don't belong in special education classes. Yet, they should be taught a special way. The schools out there for kids with autism tend to be incredibly expensive. (The one near us is $25,000 one year, every year.) I know there are teachers who are fantastic and really try their best to teach J, but I also know there are teachers who do the bare minimum because, honestly, they signed up to teach children, not special ed kids. Teachers who want to teach special ed have degrees in it. I feel we really try to mold and force kids like J to be as normal as everyone else, to fit in perfectly, but they're a puzzle piece that doesn't fit quite right. We can't treat them as special needs kids half the time, but then force them to go to schools that aren't equipped for their special needs. We can't have them be special and normal simultaneously.
There are a few things J has a strong interest in and I wish I had time to help foster those things. Art is the main one; J is an amazing artist. I've wanted to have him take art classes/lessons for the last couple years, but between therapy, his new autism friendship club, and my work schedule, I don't have the time to also schedule in an art class. It actually makes me kind of sad, because I think it's very important for a child like J to really have something he excels at. So often he hears what he is doing wrong, how he needs to fix his behavior, that he needs to change something, do something different. I'd like to be able to focus on something he is doing right - and doing well. If I could schedule J's therapy or art any time during the day, so much time would be saved. As it is now, he gets off the bus a little after 3pm, so the time we have to do things is very short-lived, especially when we have to do homework and school projects during that time as well.
I imagine if I had time during the day to focus on J's school, then in the afternoons, I could focus on Iron Man's activities so that we would have more time for his wants and needs. Is that realistic? Or feasible? I don't know.
I know there are kids who make fun of J now. He's only in third grade, but there a couple kids who tease him. It's not malicious, and I'm not even sure he understands what is going on, but it happens. Kids can be mean the older they get, especially in middle school. I would rather be proactive than subject J to a school year of misery. He's beginning to realize he is different and he's beginning to question it. Why is he different? Why aren't the other kids all different, too?
The socializing aspect of homeschool is not something I am concerned about. We are involved in an autism group that allows friendships with kids who are like him. There are homeschool art and music classes, homeschool co-ops for field trips and get togethers. There are homeschool clubs and sports teams. There are enough socializing resources out there that I don't think we would have to be concerned for his socialization. Besides, he is socially behind all the other kids in his grade because he is a few years behind them maturity-wise, so allowing him more time to mature and grow before being around people his own age might end up being helpful for him.
The socializing aspect of homeschool is not something I am concerned about. We are involved in an autism group that allows friendships with kids who are like him. There are homeschool art and music classes, homeschool co-ops for field trips and get togethers. There are homeschool clubs and sports teams. There are enough socializing resources out there that I don't think we would have to be concerned for his socialization. Besides, he is socially behind all the other kids in his grade because he is a few years behind them maturity-wise, so allowing him more time to mature and grow before being around people his own age might end up being helpful for him.
Stormtrooper doesn't believe in the preemptive pulling of J out of public school if he's doing "fine" now. That we should wait to see if he's bullied or if he struggles in his classes. And he's probably right (to an extent). Of course, he doesn't believe in pulling him even if there are struggles, because for Stormtrooper, J has to learn how to deal with real life. He can't run away from all his problems or expect a parent to solve them for him. I agree. However, I would hope that when the time comes for him to get a job, that he will be upfront with his boss and tell him he has Autism Spectrum Disorder, and he will have a job that will be flexible in regards to the things J struggles with. And if there are jerks who make fun of him, I hope he has a job with a strong HR department who will take care of the problem. But we don't necessarily have those advantages in public school. There is also a wide range of what "fine" is. Is fine simply surviving school? Is fine excelling? Is fine doing the minimal, passable work? Is fine having no friends, or no friends who will stick up for you?
What is fine?
The other issue Stormtrooper and I have gone back and forth about is the worry that by homeschooling J, I would forsake the other children (and husband!) in the house in an attempt to teach. That I wouldn't have time for focus on anyone else. I wouldn't have time for housework or regular work. I wouldn't have time for Slytherin Mama type things. I don't know if this is true or not. I do know that I require less "me" time than Stormtrooper does and I am happier being at the house doing house-children-type things than he. I think finding time to do things I want to do, or need to do, would probably take forethought, but parents manage to homeschool all the time without their houses being condemned for lack of cleanliness or losing one kid because the focus is schooling another.
For me, mostly it boils down to two things. First, I don't think that public schools are fully able to allow the time and resources to teach J in a thoughtful way since he is a special needs kid but not one that belongs in a stereotypical special needs class. I think his teachers do a great job - this year. I don't know what next year or the next will bring. I honestly don't know how much fight I have in me to make sure he receives the education he deserves with the resources they have, and updating IEPs and getting his needs met at school can often be a huge fight. Almost every year I have left IEP meetings in tears because no one seems to care about my son. This school was different, yes, but he has caring teachers. Even then, his IEP is not allows followed and I have to write notes or emails pointing that out. Second, I do have a large I-want-to-protect-my-children bone. I want to protect him from the kids who will make fun of him before he is emotionally ready to stand up to them; I do want to protect him from the teachers who will resist helping him. I've encountered those teachers and it's almost worse than the kids because they are the adults, the ones supposed to be helping. But is it wrong to take him away from school before anything happens? What if he ends up actually doing fine? But what if he doesn't? What if school starts to go south in October or November and I'm stuck keeping him in a school for months, waiting for the school year to end so I can enroll him in a different school for the next school year?
Since it appears most of the online schools only take applications in the springtime (before April really hits), we would only have a few days to make a decision for fourth grade. So this is something we will put on the shelf until this time next year where we can make a decision for fifth grade. Which is probably not a terrible thing; I think Stormtrooper is tired of talking about it. Bless him.
Being a parent is so ridiculous sometimes. I always want what's best for my kids, but since I cannot look into the future and predict anything with certainty, I'm left with making decisions with a lot of unknowns. And the unknowns can be a very frightening thing.
For me, mostly it boils down to two things. First, I don't think that public schools are fully able to allow the time and resources to teach J in a thoughtful way since he is a special needs kid but not one that belongs in a stereotypical special needs class. I think his teachers do a great job - this year. I don't know what next year or the next will bring. I honestly don't know how much fight I have in me to make sure he receives the education he deserves with the resources they have, and updating IEPs and getting his needs met at school can often be a huge fight. Almost every year I have left IEP meetings in tears because no one seems to care about my son. This school was different, yes, but he has caring teachers. Even then, his IEP is not allows followed and I have to write notes or emails pointing that out. Second, I do have a large I-want-to-protect-my-children bone. I want to protect him from the kids who will make fun of him before he is emotionally ready to stand up to them; I do want to protect him from the teachers who will resist helping him. I've encountered those teachers and it's almost worse than the kids because they are the adults, the ones supposed to be helping. But is it wrong to take him away from school before anything happens? What if he ends up actually doing fine? But what if he doesn't? What if school starts to go south in October or November and I'm stuck keeping him in a school for months, waiting for the school year to end so I can enroll him in a different school for the next school year?
Since it appears most of the online schools only take applications in the springtime (before April really hits), we would only have a few days to make a decision for fourth grade. So this is something we will put on the shelf until this time next year where we can make a decision for fifth grade. Which is probably not a terrible thing; I think Stormtrooper is tired of talking about it. Bless him.
Being a parent is so ridiculous sometimes. I always want what's best for my kids, but since I cannot look into the future and predict anything with certainty, I'm left with making decisions with a lot of unknowns. And the unknowns can be a very frightening thing.